Cressi Comanche RailBest overall- Length
- 75 cm
- Barrel
- 28 mm anti-corrosion aluminum
- Bands
- 16 mm black latex
- Reel mount
- Dovetail
Most recommended by reviewers
Check price at AmazonWe earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. How this works.
Your first speargun is an important decision. Too long and you can't maneuver it on a reef. Too weak and you lose fish. Too cheap and the trigger gives out after a season. Plenty of spearos have bought one gun, then replaced it within a year because it didn't fit the water they actually dive.
Our top pick is the Cressi Comanche Rail 75 cm, a rail sling gun that suits most beginners and keeps working as they improve. If you want something smaller, wood, pneumatic or low-cost, the other picks cover those cases.
1 Cressi Comanche Rail | 2 Cressi Apache | 3 Mares Bandit | 4 AB Biller Special Series | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Best overall | Best budget starter | Best sling entry gun | Best wooden speargun |
| Length | 75 cm | 35 cm | 75 cm | Not listed |
| Barrel | 28 mm anti-corrosion aluminum | Anodized sealed aluminum | Not listed | Grooved mahogany |
| Bands | 16 mm black latex | Not listed | 16 mm circular | Not listed |
| Muzzle | Not listed | Closed | Enclosed, extra band possible | Not listed |
| Shaft | Not listed | Tahitian-style flopper | 7 mm Sharkfin | 5/16" stainless, double barb tip |
| Check price at Amazon | Check price at Amazon | Check price at Amazon | Check price at Amazon |
Cressi Comanche RailBest overallMost recommended by reviewers
Check price at Amazon
Cressi ApacheBest budget starter
Mares BanditBest sling entry gun
AB Biller Special SeriesBest wooden speargun




A proven aluminum rail gun that fits most reef and nearshore hunting.
Most recommended by reviewers
Check price at AmazonPrices and availability on Amazon change often.
The Cressi Comanche is the speargun we'd pick for most people, thanks to its strong power, a barrel that resists bending and a design that leaves room to grow.
Reviewers report plenty of power even on the first loading notch, and the 28 mm anti-corrosion aluminum barrel is built to resist bending. The dovetail reel mount, line ring and sternal support for reloading are all thoughtful touches at this level. It also comes in several lengths, so you can size up later without switching brands. Owners on r/Spearfishing report that the Cressi Comanche is a good gun for the price, with a sturdy handle and a good trigger mechanism.
The short bands make loading harder, and many users suggest swapping in longer ones. The wishbone can also break over time, so plan on replacing parts eventually. Owner opinions on the Cressi brand are split, but the Comanche's features and reviewer feedback keep it on top for us.
If it's not for you, the Mares Bandit suits newcomers who want quick sling reloads and the option to add a second band, while the AB Biller mahogany gun suits experienced spearos who prefer a wood barrel.
The Comanche has been around for decades and still holds up as a first serious speargun. The 28 mm aluminum barrel stays straight, the handle angle helps you aim, and the release is gentle on the shaft.
At 75 cm it works for reef, kelp and moderate visibility, and the same design comes in longer sizes. Many owners swap to longer bands for easier loading, which is a cheap fix.





A small, cheap gun for small to medium fish and young or new hunters.
Prices and availability on Amazon change often.
The Apache is a gentle way into the sport. It is small enough to carry anywhere and easy to load, which matters if you are young or still learning.
Treat it as a close-range tool for small fish. Once you want bigger targets, you will want a longer gun.




A simple, comfortable beginner gun with room to add power.
Prices and availability on Amazon change often.
The Bandit is described as a comfortable, safe entry gun, and its enclosed muzzle gives you a path to more power without buying a new gun. The 7 mm Sharkfin shaft matches the advice experienced hunters give for a first gun.




A classic wooden gun with neutral buoyancy and a quiet shot.
Prices and availability on Amazon change often.
Wood guns are preferred by many experienced spearos because they absorb noise and stay stable in the water. The Special Series gives you that in a compact length that suits reef hunting.
It is a gun for people who like a traditional feel and are happy to look after it.
Set a budget first, then buy the best gun inside it. Owners stress a good trigger mechanism and a 7 to 7.5 mm shark fin or tri-cut spring steel shaft. Size to your water: shorter guns for low visibility, 90 to 110 cm when you can see further.
There isn't one best type. Band (sling) guns are simple and affordable, wood guns absorb noise and stay stable, roller guns add power for bigger fish, and pneumatic guns skip band loading. Match the type to your water and target fish.
A 75 to 110 cm aluminum band gun with a good trigger and a shark fin shaft is a common first choice. The Cressi Comanche and Mares Bandit are both easy to use and leave room to grow.
For reef and low-visibility water, a closed-muzzle gun around 75 to 90 cm is easy to maneuver. For larger fish and clear water, hunters move to 100 to 110 cm or longer with more bands.
A speargun fires a shaft using rubber bands or compressed air and has a trigger. A harpoon or pole spear is thrown or thrust by hand. Guns give greater range and a shorter learning curve.
Why trust CheckedBest
This shortlist comes from comparing current Amazon listings against what forum members, owners and spearfishing guides keep recommending. We looked at barrel length, shaft, release system, build and price, and kept only guns you can order right now.
Our expert team tests products when it is needed and researches online and in interviews. Every guide is fact-checked and edited by a real person.
The CheckedBest editorial team · Updated Oct 28, 2026
How we pickEditorial standardsAffiliate disclosureReport a mistake
We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. It never decides the winner.