TaylorMade Spider TourBest overall- Style
- Mallet
- Length
- 34 in
- Hand
- Right
- Insert
- Pure Roll TPU
Most recommended by reviewers
Check price at AmazonWe earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. How this works.
Most golfers I know will happily pour money into a new driver, then keep the same old putter for a decade. Yet the putter is the club you reach for more than any other, and a stroke that feels off on the green can ruin an otherwise good round. If putts keep sliding off line or missing the sweet spot, a new putter is one of the cheapest ways to fix it.
The TaylorMade Spider Tour is our top pick: stable, easy to aim, and recommended by several reviewers. The Odyssey Jailbird Mini adds a soft insert at a lower price, the Ping Anser 2D suits blade fans, the Cleveland HB Soft 2 is the value buy, and the PGM mallet covers a tight budget.
1 TaylorMade Spider Tour | 2 Odyssey AI-Dual Jailbird Mini | 3 Ping Scottsdale Anser 2D | 4 Cleveland HB Soft 2 | 5 PGM Mallet Putter | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Best overall | Best soft feel | Best blade | Best value | Best budget |
| Style | Mallet | Mallet | Blade | Blade | Mallet |
| Length | 34 in | 35 in | 34 in | 35 in | 35 in |
| Hand | Right | Right | Not listed | Right | Right |
| Insert | Pure Roll TPU | Dual-layer urethane | PEBAX | Not listed | Not listed |
| Check price at Amazon | Check price at Amazon | Check price at Amazon | Check price at Amazon | Check price at Amazon |
TaylorMade Spider TourBest overallMost recommended by reviewers
Check price at Amazon
Odyssey AI-Dual Jailbird MiniBest soft feel
Ping Scottsdale Anser 2DBest blade
Cleveland HB Soft 2Best value
PGM Mallet PutterBest budget
A high-MOI mallet that keeps putts on line when you miss the center.
Most recommended by reviewers
Check price at AmazonPrices and availability on Amazon change often.
The Spider Tour is the putter we'd pick for most golfers, pairing big-mallet stability with an easy-to-read look and a soft, true roll.
This is a high-MOI mallet, and reviewers call it one of the strongest performers for forgiveness and stability, with perimeter weighting that cuts down on twisting at impact. The bold True Path alignment makes it easy to aim, and the soft Pure Roll TPU insert with angled grooves is built to encourage a consistent forward roll. It also placed second in a 2026 best-in-class putter test. Owners on r/GolfGear report that the Spider Tour helps them hold a start line and make short putts, with one owner saying they can make every putt within 12 feet when reading the green correctly.
It is one of the pricier putters on the list, so budget-minded golfers may want to look elsewhere. You are paying for the stability, the alignment and the premium feel, and not everyone needs all three.
If it's not for you, the Cleveland HB Soft 2 suits golfers who want a milled blade at a friendlier price, while the Odyssey AI-Dual Jailbird Mini is the one for those who put soft feel first.
The Spider Tour keeps weight around the edges of the head, so it twists less when you don't strike the putt perfectly. That helps most golfers, especially on short putts under pressure.
The True Path alignment lines make it simple to set up square, and the soft white insert gives a smooth roll. Reviewers who put several Spider models side by side kept coming back to the Tour for its balance of feel and stability.




A half-ball mallet with a soft dual-layer insert and good stability.
Prices and availability on Amazon change often.
The dual-layer insert pairs a soft outer layer with a firm inner one, so ball speed stays even across the face. The result is a putter that feels soft but still rolls true.
The compact half-ball mallet shape is stable and the alignment aid is easy to read. Because it is face-balanced, it works best if your stroke is fairly straight back and through.





A classic Anser blade with a softer insert and extra forgiveness.
Prices and availability on Amazon change often.
If you love the look of a traditional blade but want a softer feel, this is the one to try. The lightweight PEBAX insert gives a smooth sound and forward roll.
The wide Anser shape adds a little forgiveness, and the silver line on a black head is easy to aim. It suits golfers with a slight arc in their stroke.





A milled face and a toe-hang option at a fair price.
Prices and availability on Amazon change often.
Cleveland's milling pattern helps keep distance consistent across the face, a feature you usually pay more for. It is built for golfers with a straight or slight-arc stroke.
A 20 gram weight in the butt end keeps the swing feel steady at longer lengths. It is a smart buy if you want quality without a premium price.





A cheap high-MOI mallet with a clear alignment line.
Prices and availability on Amazon change often.
For the price of a sleeve of balls you get a stable mallet with a bold alignment line. It is a good way to try a mallet before spending serious money.
Don't expect the soft feel of the premium models, but for casual rounds or a first putter it covers the basics well.
Start with your stroke. If you swing the putter straight back and through, a face-balanced mallet like the Spider or Jailbird fits well. If you open and close the face in a slight arc, a blade or toe-hang model like the Anser or HB Soft suits you better.
Then think about forgiveness. Mallets resist twisting on off-center hits and are easier to aim, which is why most reviewers point beginners to them. Blades give more feel but demand cleaner contact.
Finally, check the length. Most golfers between 5-foot-8 and 6-foot-2 do well at 34 to 35 inches, and a fitting can fine-tune the rest.
Reviewers' rankings vary by test, but mallets like the LAB OZ.1 and the TaylorMade Spider Tour X have topped recent lists. Among the putters here, the Spider Tour is our favorite for its stability and easy alignment.
A high-MOI mallet like the Spider Tour or Odyssey Jailbird Mini is a good choice, because it stays steadier on mishits and is easier to line up.
The Cleveland HB Soft 2 offers a milled face and thoughtful design at a fair price. If you want to spend even less, the PGM mallet covers the basics.
Match the putter to your stroke: straight strokes suit face-balanced mallets, arcing strokes suit toe-hang blades. Check the length for your height, and try a few if you can, since feel varies a lot.
Both can be excellent. Mallets are usually better for forgiveness and alignment, while blades suit consistent strikers who prefer feel and feedback.
The shortlist above reflects what's in stock and well regarded right now, led by the TaylorMade Spider Tour, with strong options for soft feel, blade fans, value and tight budgets.
Why trust CheckedBest
This shortlist is built from putters we compared side by side on their listings, then matched against what golf reviewers recommend. Every pick is in stock right now, and we weighed forgiveness, feel, alignment and value for different strokes and budgets.
Our expert team tests products when it is needed and researches online and in interviews. Every guide is fact-checked and edited by a real person.
The CheckedBest editorial team · Updated Oct 26, 2026
How we pickEditorial standardsAffiliate disclosureReport a mistake
We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. It never decides the winner.