First Lie Wins by Ashley ElstonTop pick- Format
- Paperback
- Publisher
- Penguin
Most recommended by reviewers
Check price at Amazon
First Lie Wins by Ashley ElstonTop pickRunner-up2
None of This Is True by Lisa JewellBest for something differentWe earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. How this works.
Mystery readers usually have to choose between a fast, twisty plot and a deeper, slower story with richer characters. The Best Mystery Books of 2025 list covers both ends, from gripping thrillers to literary and historical puzzles.
First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston gets that balance right, with constant plot twists and a pace that makes it easy to read in one sitting. The rest of the list offers different tastes, from time-travel to atmospheric suspense.
1 First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston | 2 None of This Is True by Lisa Jewell | 3 Then She Was Gone by Lisa Jewell | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Top pick | Best for something different | Best for historical mystery |
| Format | Paperback | Paperback | Paperback |
| Publisher | Penguin | Atria Books | Atria Books |
| Check price at Amazon | Check price at Amazon | Check price at Amazon |
First Lie Wins by Ashley ElstonTop pickMost recommended by reviewers
Check price at Amazon
None of This Is True by Lisa JewellBest for something different
Then She Was Gone by Lisa JewellBest for historical mystery
A fast, twisty thriller that bloggers say is hard to put down.
Most recommended by reviewers
Check price at AmazonPrices and availability on Amazon change often.
One catchTwists are the main draw, so readers who want slow character work may find it thin.

A psychological mystery built on a podcast host and a secret, for readers who like suspense.
Prices and availability on Amazon change often.


A mystery about a missing teenager and the family left behind, for readers who want emotional depth.
Prices and availability on Amazon change often.
Start with First Lie Wins if you want a fast, twisty read. Choose a psychological pick if you like suspense that builds slowly. Go for the historical or emotional pick if you want more depth.
First Lie Wins is our top pick for its steady plot twists. The Edge of the Woods and On a Quiet Street are solid alternatives.
This list gives the three best picks for this search. Expert reviews also mention several other titles that are not currently in stock on Amazon.
Psychological thrillers like None of This Is True suit fall reading. Pick by the pace you enjoy.
Ratings aren't part of our research, so we can't name the top-rated book. The picks here are chosen by expert and retailer sources.
The picks on this page are 2025 titles. Check release dates before buying if you want newer releases.
The picks here are not split by audience, but First Lie Wins and None of This Is True are good fits for readers who like fast, plot-driven mysteries.
Meet the reviewer

Content Reviewer & Fact-Checker
I’m an e-commerce content reviewer and fact-checker with a background in copywriting and over six years of professional experience. My experience in creating and refining digital content allows me to assess product information, review written content for accuracy and clarity, and help ensure shoppers have access to reliable, informative and engaging content.
Why trust CheckedBest
Our shortlist is built from five expert reviews and a retailer list, cross-checked against current Amazon listings. Every pick below is in stock and available to order now.
Our expert team tests products when it is needed and researches online and in interviews. Every guide is fact-checked and edited by a real person.
The CheckedBest editorial team · Updated Nov 8, 2026
How we pickEditorial standardsAffiliate disclosureReport a mistake
We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. It never decides the winner.