The Best Dark Chocolate Bars

We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. How this works.

Dark chocolate is a bigger jump than most people expect, and the right bar depends on how bitter or fruity you like it. Taste tests keep returning to one bar: Theo 70% Cacao is the No. 1 pick, a balanced, smooth dark bar that is easy to enjoy. Our runner-up, Lindt Excellence 85%, is the choice if you want a much stronger, more intense cocoa hit.

Our shortlist covers a range of cocoa levels, flavors and budgets, so you can start where you're comfortable and move up.

The rundown

1Theo Organic 70%, Dark Chocolate BarsTheo Organic 70%2Lindt Excellence 85%, Dark Chocolate BarsLindt Excellence 85%3Lindt Excellence 90%, Dark Chocolate BarsLindt Excellence 90%4Ghirardelli Premium Dark 86%, Dark Chocolate BarsGhirardelli Premium Dark 86%
Best forBest overallStrongest cocoaBest for holiday sharingBest budget
Cocoa70%85%90%86%
Pack6 x 3 oz bars12 x 3.5 oz bars4 x 3.5 oz barsNot listed
CertificationsOrganic, Fair Trade, veganNot listedNot listedKosher
Check price at AmazonCheck price at AmazonCheck price at AmazonCheck price at Amazon
1Best overall
Theo Organic 70%, Dark Chocolate BarsTheo Organic 70%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 2Theo Organic 70%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 3Theo Organic 70%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 4Theo Organic 70%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 5
1 / 5

Theo Organic 70%

A balanced, smooth 70% bar that works as a first step into dark chocolate.

Cocoa
70%
Pack
6 x 3 oz bars
Certifications
Organic, Fair Trade, vegan

Most recommended by reviewers

Check price at Amazon

Prices and availability on Amazon change often.

Why we picked the Theo Organic 70%

For a dark chocolate that is easy to enjoy, the Theo Organic 70% Cacao bars are the pick we'd start with.

What we like

The Theo bars strike a balance that reviewers say is rare in dark chocolate, with flavor that is neither sweet nor bitter and a smooth, pleasant texture. Several tasters in one expert review called it the best one so far, and one described it as a good introduction to dark chocolate. Each of the six 3 oz bars is individually wrapped, and the bars are organic, Fair Trade, soy free and vegan, which makes them a sensible choice for gifting or sharing.

Worth knowing

The trade-off is boldness. A few tasters found the flavor a little flat or mid compared with more intense bars, so if you already love very high cocoa chocolate, the Lindt 85% or Ghirardelli 86% may suit you better. The Theo bars are also a 70% cacao, so they are less intense than those options from the start.

If it's not for you, the Lindt Excellence 85% suits people who want a stronger cocoa punch in pre-portioned squares, and the Ghirardelli 86% is a low-cost single bar for trying a bolder flavor before committing to more.

Read our full take

Why it's our top pick

In a blind taste test by The Guardian, Theo 70% Cacao was named the best dark chocolate, with several tasters calling it the best bar they had tried. It is approachable for a dark bar, so it suits people who are moving up from milk chocolate.

The organic, Fair Trade and vegan certifications also suit buyers who care about sourcing.

2Strongest cocoa
Lindt Excellence 85%, Dark Chocolate BarsLindt Excellence 85%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 2Lindt Excellence 85%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 3Lindt Excellence 85%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 4Lindt Excellence 85%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 5
1 / 5

Lindt Excellence 85%

A robust, silky 85% bar for people who want deep cocoa flavor.

Cocoa
85%
Pack
12 x 3.5 oz bars
Format
Pre-portioned squares
Check price at Amazon

Prices and availability on Amazon change often.

Pros

  • Well-balanced, robust cocoa notes
  • Silky feel
  • Pre-portioned, easy to share

Cons

  • Strongly bitter for people new to dark chocolate
  • Less sweet than the 70% bars
Read our full take

Why we like it

Lindt Excellence 85% is built for people who already like dark chocolate and want more cocoa. The flavor is robust but still smooth, and the pre-portioned squares make it easy to control how much you eat.

It works well after dinner or in baking. If you find 85% too intense, the 70% Lindt bar is a gentler step.

3Best for holiday sharing
Lindt Excellence 90%, Dark Chocolate BarsLindt Excellence 90%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 2Lindt Excellence 90%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 3Lindt Excellence 90%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 4Lindt Excellence 90%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 5
1 / 5

Lindt Excellence 90%

A 90% bar with roasted coffee notes, sold in a four-pack for sharing.

Cocoa
90%
Pack
4 x 3.5 oz bars
Notes
Roasted coffee, cocoa
Check price at Amazon

Prices and availability on Amazon change often.

Pros

  • Roasted coffee and cocoa notes
  • Good for dessert boards and gifts
  • Pairs well with coffee or red wine

Cons

  • Very bitter for most casual eaters
  • Higher cocoa means a more intense bar
Read our full take

Why it's on the list

This 90% Lindt bar suits people who want the most intense cocoa in the range. The roasted coffee notes stand out, and it pairs well with an espresso or a Malbec.

The four-pack is a good size for holiday sharing or dessert boards, but it is strong, so it works best for people who already enjoy very dark chocolate.

4Best budget
Ghirardelli Premium Dark 86%, Dark Chocolate BarsGhirardelli Premium Dark 86%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 2Ghirardelli Premium Dark 86%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 3Ghirardelli Premium Dark 86%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 4Ghirardelli Premium Dark 86%, Dark Chocolate Bars, view 5
1 / 5

Ghirardelli Premium Dark 86%

A bold 86% bar with dark cherry and dried plum notes at a low single-bar price.

Cocoa
86%
Size
3.17 oz bar
Certifications
Kosher
Check price at Amazon

Prices and availability on Amazon change often.

Pros

  • Deep flavor with dark cherry and dried plum notes
  • Smooth, slow-melting texture
  • Low price per bar

Cons

  • Intense for people new to dark chocolate
  • Single bar, so it suits trying before buying more
Read our full take

Why it's on the list

Ghirardelli Premium Dark 86% is the lowest-cost way to try a high-cocoa bar. The cherry and dried plum notes give it more character than most bars at this price, and it melts smoothly.

It is a single 3.17 oz bar, so it is best for trying a strong dark chocolate before committing to a larger pack.

FAQ

Which dark chocolate to buy?

Start with a 70% bar if you are new to dark chocolate. Move up to 85% or 90% once you like the bitterness.

  • New to dark: Theo 70%
  • Strong cocoa: Lindt 85%
  • Sharing and gifts: Lindt 90% four-pack
  • Cheapest way to try high cocoa: Ghirardelli 86%
What to look for?

Check the ingredient list first. It should be short and start with cacao. Cocoa percentage shows sweetness rather than quality, so tasting is the only reliable test.

What is the best dark chocolate to buy?

Theo 70% Cacao is the best all-round pick. It was named the best dark chocolate in a blind taste test and is balanced enough for beginners.

How good is dark chocolate for your health?

Dark chocolate contains flavonoids and antioxidants. It is best eaten in small amounts as part of a varied diet, and it is calorie-dense.

What is the best dark chocolate for diabetics?

Look for a high-cacao bar with little added sugar, such as the Lindt Excellence 90% Cocoa Dark Chocolate Bar or the Ghirardelli Premium Dark 86% Cacao Bar. Always check the label for sugar content and talk to your doctor about how much fits your plan.

What is the best dark chocolate for weight loss?

No chocolate causes weight loss on its own. Higher-cocoa bars are more filling per piece, so a small square of a strong bar can satisfy a craving with fewer calories.

Is dark chocolate good for periods?

Some people find dark chocolate helps with cravings during their period, but the evidence is limited. Choose a bar with less sugar for steadier energy.

Which is better, 70% or 85% dark chocolate?

70% is smoother and sweeter, so it suits beginners. 85% is more bitter and intense, and suits people who already enjoy strong dark chocolate.

Why trust CheckedBest

How we made this guide

  • 4 Amazon listings compared
  • 5 editorial taste tests read
  • 4 products shown

This shortlist is built from four in-stock Amazon listings, checked against five editorial taste tests and a chocolate guide. Each pick is weighed on cocoa content, taste notes, texture and price.

Our expert team tests products when it is needed and researches online and in interviews. Every guide is fact-checked and edited by a real person.

The CheckedBest editorial team · Updated Nov 10, 2026

Checking our work: 4 sources

We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. It never decides the winner.